Signal dropouts (signal strength 30% - is this too low?)

Black Hole said:
The only reason for using the signal test on the service menu is if you suspect only one tuner is working (and clearly they are giving the same performance). So far as I know there is no option in the service menu version to change the UHF channel for the test. Using Menu >> Settings >> System >> Signal Detection doesn't offer a choice of tuner - but does allow you to survey all the tuned muxes. I recommend you do that
Click to expand...
Presumably I do that simply by selecting each transponder on the Signal Detect screen and pressing the Enter button? If so, the results show 25-30% Strength for all transponders apart from 48200MHz, which jumps between 30% and 36%.
Quality shows as 100% for all 6 transponders.
I'm using the exactly the same RF cable for the TV and Humax - unplugging the cable and switching it between the TV and the Humax.
So if the signal strength isn't good enough for the Humax (25-30%) I'm guessing that any aerial improvements could only be marginal if the TV is already reporting 93% strength? Would it be worth getting somebody up on the roof do you think?
 
everthewatcher said:
Oh yes there is - I'm looking at it now.
Click to expand...
Oh yes, so there is. Unfortunately it only displays frequency not channel number, so it is less convenient (I think in channel number, because that is what is normally used when discussing TV broadcast channels/muxes). I am bemused that the OP insists on using the service menu rather than the signal detection in the System menu.

Ian Manning said:
do I only need to search the 7 channels listed in the "N" column from the Freeview site detailed view?
Click to expand...
Yes, exactly that (and make sure you select DVB-T or DVB-T2 appropriate for each one).

Ian Manning said:
I'm guessing that any aerial improvements could only be marginal if the TV is already reporting 93% strength?
Click to expand...
Why? What signal voltage does the TV call "100%"? You don't know and I don't know either. All you know is that the Hummy is reporting 25% (or whatever) and getting dropouts. You still want to know what that looks like when the dropouts are actually happening, and the reported quality at the time. If the quality remains 100% you have to start looking at whether its disk thrashing that's causing it, rather than signal.

If the dropouts are due to signal, you might only need to lift it by a few percent.
 
Ian Manning said:
Presumably I do that simply by selecting each transponder on the Signal Detect screen and pressing the Enter button? If so, the results show 25-30% Strength for all transponders apart from 48200MHz, which jumps between 30% and 36%.
Quality shows as 100% for all 6 transponders.
Click to expand...
That's the way.
Ian Manning said:
I'm using the exactly the same RF cable for the TV and Humax - unplugging the cable and switching it between the TV and the Humax.
Click to expand...
Good - it eliminates any other variables. Only thing I might suggest is try a different flylead just in case there's an issue with it not mating properly with the HDR. Ah, that's another possibility to eliminate - is the RF in connector broken? Easy enough to check. With the TV plugged into the HDR's RF Out does the TV still report >90% (or whatever) signal strength?
Ian Manning said:
So if the signal strength isn't good enough for the Humax (25-30%) I'm guessing that any aerial improvements could only be marginal if the TV is already reporting 93% strength? Would it be worth getting somebody up on the roof do you think?
Click to expand...
It wouldn't be the first time I've seen a TV report 100% signal when the HDR reports a lot less. Here the HDR reports 75% on Ch55 (the lowest) but the Panasonic TV reports 10. If I put in a 10dB attenuator it drops to 8 with errors so it's clearly non-linear. The HDR drops from 75% to 54% with a signal quality of 100%.
 
everthewatcher said:
That's the way.

Good - it eliminates any other variables. Only thing I might suggest is try a different flylead just in case there's an issue with it not mating properly with the HDR. Ah, that's another possibility to eliminate - is the RF in connector broken? Easy enough to check. With the TV plugged into the HDR's RF Out does the TV still report >90% (or whatever) signal strength?
Click to expand...
Ah....we could be getting somewhere....if I connect the RF out from the Humax to the TV I get zero signal on the TV. So maybe the Humax's RF connector is broken? I have an old HDR-Fox T2 in the loft (broken fan IIRC). How feasible/easy is it to swap the RF hardware between units?
 
Ian Manning said:
if I connect the RF out from the Humax to the TV I get zero signal on the TV
Click to expand...
That could mean you had the Humax unpowered, or in standby with low power mode set (no pass-through), or your link cable is broken. Easy enough to insert the link cable in series with the direct cable to the TV to check.

Ian Manning said:
(broken fan IIRC). How feasible/easy is it to swap the RF hardware between units?
Click to expand...
It would be a lot easier to simply swap the fan!

https://hummy.tv/forum/threads/hdr-fox-hardware-commissioning-disassembly-repair.5728/
 
Black Hole said:
That could mean you had the Humax unpowered, or in standby with low power mode set (no pass-through), or your link cable is broken. Easy enough to insert the link cable in series with the direct cable to the TV to check.


It would be a lot easier to simply swap the fan!

https://hummy.tv/forum/threads/hdr-fox-hardware-commissioning-disassembly-repair.5728/
Click to expand...
The Humax was powered on when I tried it, so presumably would have been passing the RF signal through. I just tried taking the Humax out of the loop as you suggested - unplugging the input and output RF cables from the Humax, coupling them and sending the output to the TV. The signal was fine on the TV (93%). So the signal is being lost between the RF input and RF output on the Humax. Maybe tomorrow I should dig the old Humax out of the loft and see whether the RF signal is OK on that.
I think it was the fan connector (i.e. on the motherboard) rather than the fan itself which was broken on the old Humax. IIRC I got hold of a new replacement fan and that didn't work, but it worked in the new Humax that I'd picked up on eBay. So I stored the old Humax in the loft as a future organ donor.
 
Ian Manning said:
The Humax was powered on when I tried it, so presumably would have been passing the RF signal through. So the signal is being lost between the RF input and RF output on the Humax.
Click to expand...
Assuming no more assumptions it looks like we may have the answer. Makes me feel a bit better after screwing up elsewhere.

It wouldn't the first time an RF socket has been broken on a tuner can and I did it myself on a Sony ST-SB920 tuner last year. It's easy enough to fix if you know what you're doing but if not get someone else who knows which end of a soldering iron to hold to have a look at it.

That said, I'm not going to open an HDR to see but it should be possible to pop off the side of the 'in' tuner shielding can without taking out the PCB - I'm assuming it's the V1 with twin tuner modules and side-by-side RF connectors.
 
Ian Manning said:
I think it was the fan connector (i.e. on the motherboard) rather than the fan itself which was broken on the old Humax. IIRC I got hold of a new replacement fan and that didn't work, but it worked in the new Humax that I'd picked up on eBay. So I stored the old Humax in the loft as a future organ donor.
Click to expand...
Fair enough. If the connector itself is physically broken, that might be repairable. On the other hand it might be the driver that is broken.

Ian Manning said:
unplugging the input and output RF cables from the Humax, coupling them and sending the output to the TV. The signal was fine on the TV (93%). So the signal is being lost between the RF input and RF output on the Humax.
Click to expand...
That seems to be a reasonable conclusion. I don't think it is likely to be responsible for a decrease in signal rather than a total loss of signal (for the Humax) though. Take a look in the pass-through socket and see if the centre pin is still there.

What you could do with the broken-fan unit is run it up and see whether the reported signal strength is similar.
 
Black Hole said:
Strange idea. The Humax is reporting some signal (not no signal), but the TV reports no signal from the pass-through... so what symptoms are you thinking of?
Click to expand...
HDR reporting <<40% signal with dropouts, TV reporting >90% on the same connection, but dropping to zero when connected via the HDR RF Out.

The OP says "My T2 is increasingly losing its TV signal completely (i.e. a blank screen with the "no signal" message), or the picture is breaking up badly" so presumably it previously was fine although we have no prior signal strength measurements to help here..

The OP also says "My TV uses the same RF feed, but doesn't struggle as badly as the Humax - i.e. the live TV picture never breaks up or disappears" so clearly wasn't connected via the RF Out on the HDR.

Based on this it does look as if the issue could be with the RF In connection on the HDR. If the connection was disturbed some time just before the problem started then this could back this up.
 
Black Hole said:
... On the HDR-FOX, if you press "OK" while tuned to any particular service then press "i" (info), you will get a pop-up reporting the transmission characteristics for that service - of particular interest is the UHF channel number. ...
Click to expand...
And on the HD-Fox too, but maybe you weren't excluding that. News to me, anyway.
 
Why are 'we' using the word "transponder" reference terrestrial TV? That is a satellite term.
 
everthewatcher said:
HDR reporting <<40% signal with dropouts, TV reporting >90% on the same connection, but dropping to zero when connected via the HDR RF Out.
Click to expand...
Therefore it's the RF Out (pass-through) that's broken. If it was only the RF Input that had somehow degraded (without complete LoS), the RF Out would have a similar signal strength as the HDR-FOX is reporting. Anyway, switching in the old unit (with non-functioning fan) temporarily should prove that one way or the other.

everthewatcher said:
The OP says "My T2 is increasingly losing its TV signal completely (i.e. a blank screen with the "no signal" message), or the picture is breaking up badly" so presumably it previously was fine although we have no prior signal strength measurements to help here..
Click to expand...
We have no idea what environmental factors are involved. It is entirely possible the TV (which looks very new) has a new technology tuner with greater sensitivity and noise rejection. It is possible the 700MHz clearance programme has shifted the channels in use down to the marginal reception of the existing aerial group, and/or the propagation path has acquired new obstructions, and/or the aerial/cable is degrading. That's where I put my money (and a broken pass-through).

/df said:
And on the HD-Fox too, but maybe you weren't excluding that. News to me, anyway.
Click to expand...
You're right, I wasn't excluding the HD-FOX (but this conversation is about HDR-FOX). In a more general information post I would have specified HD/HDR-FOX.

Trev said:
Why are 'we' using the word "transponder" reference terrestrial TV? That is a satellite term.
Click to expand...
I'm not, that's for sure. I think the confusion might come from the OP's dogged use of the service menu tuner test (a lot more fiddly than the Signal Detection menu) which only reports the frequencies (similar to satellite). It is conventional to use channel numbers for UHF TV.

Why do satellite TV circles use "transponder" at all? They're not transponders from the user's point of view (or even a technical point of view) - I take "transponder" as meaning a device which responds to a received command by transmitting a response which is not the same as the stimulus (eg an IFF transponder on aircraft, which emits a signature in response to a query, or even a sonic key fob locator). Something which simply passes on what it receives is a repeater.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top