Well, for a starter, your implication that this disease only affects old or fat relatives. Why not include black and male in your insults? Or people with medical conditions?
The next insult was to link MikeSh with that creep Johnson.
The facts are that everyone is at risk, risk varies considerably, anyone could be a carrier, we don't have any way of knowing which people should be isolated and which are safe, yet, so the only way to control the spread is by asking people to isolate.
I actually agree with you about the irresponsible universities, in requiring students to return to campus. I am sure that decision was based on financial arguments and not academic.
I also see widespread failure to obey the rules amongst the general population. My personal feeling is that schools are perhaps a big spreader.
However, please distinguish between the real cause of your woes, the disease, and your perceived cause, an encroachment on your civil liberties. What we were trying to explain to you was that such encroachments have been made in the past. I accused you of nit picking because you seemed fixated on one particular case of such encroachment. And I am now saying that assuming the people being isolated are healthy is wrong, we just do not know.